Andrea
ANDREA
September 15, 2005
Boston, MA
Call up ring once hang up the phone
To let me know you made it home
Don't want nothin' to be wrong
With part time lover
“Let me be clear,” said Andrea’s 200-an-hour shrink. “Married men do not leave their wives. I really need you to understand that, if you’re going to reach your stated goal.”
“Some do,” said Andrea, thinking of her friend, Bethamy. Bethamy didn’t even want to marry this guy, and one day he just showed up on her door, flanked by two suitcases, and told her he left his wife. And he was loaded to-boot. “And anyway, this one’s only engaged, so that’s fair game, right?”
“Well, to the extent that people are together by choice, everyone is fair game, married, engaged, or otherwise,” said her therapist. “But you need to understand the pattern that you have established, and the pattern of people you find. This is – what – your sixth relationship with a man who is involved?”
Who the hell knew? As if her shrink could read her mind, the woman added, “I suspect there are more than six and this is not about coincidence, Andrea Not only are these men not available emotionally to you, but your reasons for desiring them in the first place stem from this competitive thing you have with other women. Men are only really attractive to you when you are competing for their affection with someone you believe thinks she’s better than you. It’s got to stop if what you want is a lasting relationship. There’s always time to find the right person and there’s no single way to go about it, but at 42, we generally expect that people have had at least one committed relationship.” The therapist paused and breathed, as if trying to forestall what she would say next. She folded her notebook and leaned forward. When she did speak, her voice was low.
“I’m not going to moralize on whether coming on to married men is wrong, but I know it’s a wrong choice for you because you’ve been clear about wanting a long-term partner. Sleeping with committed men excludes the likelihood that you can have a committed relationship. It’s pretty simple from a behavioral perspective.”
Andrea bit her upper lip to push back the tears. She didn’t want to cry. All she wanted was someone to love her. It was all she ever wanted. She didn’t know why she kept getting the married ones and non-committing ones. She didn’t. She looked out the window so her therapist wouldn’t see her blinking back tears. This wasn’t helping, she thought to herself. This woman is just telling me I’m a bad person. Again with the mind-reading:
“Andrea,” said her therapist, holding out a tissue box, “this is why you’re here, to work through these issues. But the thing is, you have to start with some behavioral changes. We’ll get into some of your competition issues in the weeks to come, but the behavioral change you have to make now is this: stop dating men who are already involved.”
“But they come on to me,” Andrea pointed out, remembering how Tony had approached her at the law firm mixer. Didn’t he know he was engaged at the time? This was all so unfair. It was as if she was being penalized for her charm. She hated men sometimes.
“People will approach you all the time with propositions of one kind or another. You will never be able to control that; this is about your choices,” the therapist said. “And just we are clear, it is perfectly appropriate to ask a man if he is already involved.”
Oh yeah, thought Andrea, that’s a real turn on at a party: Hi, I’m Andrea. Before we start talking, do you mind telling me if you have a girlfriend or wife? But she held her tongue, at least on that point. Besides, it wasn’t just about that. She felt real chemistry with the men she met; this wasn’t anecdotal coincidence related to the love of the same ice cream flavor, nor was it any longer just a romp in the sack. Perhaps years ago the latter might have been a motivator, but now she had no reason to waste her time on involved men. Andrea was looking for a mate – and she was finding them. She wanted to give that a chance. These were deeper connections that mere physical attraction.
“How do you just stop being attracted to someone,” Andrea challenged the shrink.
“Andrea, this is a dangerous game you’re playing with yourself, creating a monomaniacal fiction that these men are the only ones for you and that they feel the same way. How many ‘he’s-the-only-one-for-me’ men have you had? And in every case, they’ve ended badly. Remember the lawyer?”
She remembered. She had met Derek at a party. And while the ring on his finger told her he was probably married, it didn’t signal that he was married to a ruthless bitch.
In short order, he had become the love of her life and she knew the feeling was mutual. He had asked her to be patient; that he and his wife were going through a bad patch, but that if things continued to go south with his wife, he would make their relationship permanent. He empathized with her status, and often commented on the strength and self-confidence it took to be content with a non-traditional relationship. He often commented on her elevated spiritual plane of operation and her independence, which he found sexy. Then, without notice, he told her it was off. He was going to try to make a go of it. His wife was pregnant and he was happy and their good times were nothing more than a fling. Poof! Gone. Kicked to the curb like Monday’s trash.
Their talks had been too intense, their sex too intimate for merely a fling. He had bared his heart to her. She knew his deepest fears and he hers. She had recently counseled him in a real estate purchase that he said was an investment, she assumed, for his and Andrea’s future. Why else would he buy property in Natick if not for a little home to raise their children. Their future. They even talked about what baby names the liked. He called her every day, even sent flowers to her office (love, me). This sudden privation was his wife’s unborn baby talking, not Derek.
Surely, his wife would be inclined to leave him if she knew the truth of their spiritual connection. It was pretty clear that a wife who was 24-7 at the office wasn’t providing him with what he needed, or else why would Derek be coming to Andrea? By revealing herself as his true soul mate, Andrea wasn’t trying to hurt anyone (though she knew someone would be hurt), she was merely trying to create a space for her and Derek. Men, by their nature, were cowardly, so she couldn’t count on him to do the right thing for the two of them. Thinking about it then, their connection was positively compulsory, and in the end, by revealing the true nature of their relationship to his wife, Andrea was really only accelerating the inevitable. She found the wife’s email address (not hard, using the web) and sent an email from her office account.
you don’t know me but your husband is my boyfriend
That’s how the email began. It went on to suggest that the two women talk. Andrea made sure the email was tasteful and dignified, not some seamy or nasty communication that might be seen on Jerry Springer. After all, there was another woman involved who would surely be hurt by what was contained in it. It was only right to consider her feelings in all this.
There had been no response for a week; neither had Derek returned her phone calls. Perhaps they were working out the separation between them; how and when he would leave. She would do the right thing and give him space. Then, the phone rang.
“What are you? Some sort of serial fuck-buddy?” said the woman at the other end of the phone. Andrea knew instantly who it was.
“There’s no need to be nasty,” said Andrea, trying to keep her composure.
“Let me get this straight: you spread your legs for my husband and I’m the one who’s nasty? Does a wedding ring mean anything to you?”
“Derek loves me.”
“Is that what you think?” the woman on the other end had started to chuckle. “You really are pathetic. Let me set you straight. First, Derek has done this before, and just so we’re clear, when he got busted this time, his excuse was that he used you for free legal advice for our vacation home. And I’ve done my homework on you. Before you started sleeping with every married man in Boston, maybe you should have thought about your college days. USC Sorority girls grow up and get morals! Some do, anyway. Your pink-and-green sisters tell me you’re all about the married men like it’s some sickness. Well, you fucked with the wrong bitch this time, you fucking cunt.”
“I don’t need to listen to this,” said Andrea, indignant that her attempts at civility were being rebuked. “I was trying to save you and your baby the pain of being in a loveless relationship.”
“Oh is that how you justify it? Where are my manners. Here’s how I’m showing my gratitude. Remember John Kinney? Guess whose wife just got saved too.”
“That is none of your business,” snapped Andrea. “Anyway, what do you know? You can’t prove any thing.”
“You shouldn’t share certain, shall we say fellatious, Polaroids with your girlfriends, honey. Oh yeah, I can prove it alright. And I got a list of more names, too. I plan do save women all over the tri-state area, which appears to be your hunting ground. My marriage may be over, but so are you. “
Andrea had tried to remain calm. This was backfiring in a big way. “I can sue you for defamation, and you should know I’m an attorney.”
“I’m an attorney, too, bitch. Let me give you a torts lesson since you obviously missed it in first year law school: it’s only actionable if it’s false.” Then she had hung up.
Things had not worked as planned, and to save herself, Andrea called a friend in the city attorney’s office for advice on how to stave off this woman’s campaign. Without thinking, he agreed to write a nasty letter, on City Attorney letterhead, threatening legal action and an ethics investigation if the woman disparaged Andrea. In hindsight, it had been stupid at so many levels. Derek’s wife had gotten the friend fired, and she never heard from Derek again (though she did get a certain satisfaction upon hearing of his divorce). Perhaps if she had handled it differently, they’d still be together.
Andrea left the bad memory and sank into her therapist’s leather armchair. That had not been a good break-up, but at least she was right about the marriage. She turned to her therapist.
“I agree that breakup was a mess, but first of all, I was right, wasn’t I? It was a loveless marriage. And second of all, it wasn’t my fault how things turned out. Who knew that woman would be so crazy.”
“This is always someone else’s fault, isn’t it, Andrea?” the therapist said. “Tell me, do you shoulder any of the responsibility for the things that affect you?”
“Of course. I’m here, aren’t I? I just don’t think I should be the villain all the time. I’m giving these men something they need, they obviously gravitate to me because of who I am, and it’s not up to me to sustain their marriages, is it?”
“That’s a moral question that has more to do with the type of society you want to live in and how you feel about supporting the choices that other people make,” said the therapist. “We’re not necessarily here to change the world; we’re here to get you what you want. That said, remember that the shoe could be on the other foot someday, Andrea, and you want to know that strangers out there support – or at least respect -- your choice to be in a monogamous relationship.”
“ Well, I don’t support people being miserable and you know, these men are miserable before they come to me. I don’t force anyone to sleep with me. They are obviously still searching for something and they find me.”
“Is this way of relationship building getting you what you want in life?”
“If it were, would I be sitting here?” Andrea’s sarcasm and general annoyance and pedantic women like her shrink was beginning to show. “I’m just saying that I’m not a bad person.”
Her therapist smiled at her and put down the tissue box. She spoke softly. “I know all of this is tough.. We’ll talk next week. Remember that therapy is based upon your own self-reporting, and your own hard look at your behavior. I have to trust what you tell me, but I’ve also been in this game long enough to know all the tricks. To move past your issues, you have to be honest with yourself and with me. I’ll see you next week?”
CHAPTER TWO
Andrea nodded and shook off the comfort of the leather chair to get her coat. Though she knew the time, she instinctively looked at her watch 6:50pm. The September weather was prescient of cooler temperatures to come, but today, it was a perfect Boston night. Maybe a drink on the patio at Rivaud. Or some drinks and soup at the Harvest across Smoots bridge in Cambridge. Andrea’s psychologist meeting today precluded a visit to the gym, so she decided to walk.. She punched in the number of a girlfriend, but left no message when voicemail picked up. She tried another. And another. Dinner for one, it seemed, was on the menu. She contemplated briefly having dinner at a bar, but decided she wasn’t in the mood for flirting tonight. A quiet evening at the Harvest in Cambridge might be the perfect place to nest. She would stop by the bookstore and pick up something juicy.
These days, fewer and fewer of her girlfriends could make a last minute dinner invitation. Most were encumbered in some way: married, partnered, kids. Her impromptu invitations competed head-to-head with their bake sale duties, television shows, or just the need to be with their families. All too often, she was the barfly at the end of the night, flirting with some drunk investment banker whose T card and cash had fallen out of his pocket and who was trying to figure out his own phone number. Left and right, her friends were “calling it a night” well before she was ready to reacquaint with the newly painted walls of her Back Bay condo. They never had time for her any more. Time was all she had, except, it seemed, for finding a soul mate.
When they did meet her for the occasional lunch or evening drink, they frequently managed to make married life sound horrific. Husband X did this or that thing to piss them off; they were overworked; kids were a pain; sex was non-existent; no time alone. And most of them had let themselves go to the point where Andrea would not have been surprised if their men were getting it on the side, too. To top it off, their muffin top waistlines were stuffed into outfits that should have been put out to Goodwill two years ago. Andrea wouldn’t paint her house in some of the getups they sported outside. To hear them tell it, single life was a welcome breeze in a stifling way of life. They were not only physical blobs, but many of them were bereft of any spiritual intelligence.
Still, it’s one thing to complain about the quality of the sheets when you stay at the Four Season’s, but if you’ve never been there, it’s difficult to sympathize. Although many of her erstwhile hottie friends had become harried, homely, and fat, their complaints rang hollow in Andrea’s ears. She, after all, was not part of the married woman’s club. And at least according to Time Magazine, if you were over 35 and single, you had more chance of being hit by lightening than finding a partner.
They always asked her about the new love in her life, but over time she’d stopped providing too much detail. For one thing, unlike her shrink, her married friends had taken to moralizing about her choices. It wasn’t just the being involved thing, it was her choices in men, generally and/or her reasons for gravitating toward them, all of which was fair game to the married crowd. God forbid you mention that they were letting themselves go, but get one gray hair and suddenly they were all telling her that she ought to cover it up or risk appearing long in the tooth. And there was the age thing. Andrea knew they were trying to help, but there were certain girlfriends who had a way of making her want to slit her wrists in a warm bath.
“Girl, at 42, you really do need to lie about your marital status. People will think you are retarded or something if you haven’t been married at least once. You can always tell him the truth after he’s asked you to marry him,” they’d say. Great, now she was a loser because she hadn’t been divorced? Another one she could see coming from miles away was the maybe-you’re-gay sermon:
“You know, Andrea, there’s nothing wrong with not being attracted to men. This is the 21st century. People don’t care about, you know, if you have a preference for women. In fact, I have a friend who ---- .“ That’s how it would begin.
And despite all of their man-getting advice and helpful suggestions, what was conspicuously missing from their chocolate martini and French fry dinners was the invitation by any of her “friends” to meet an eligible man. At first, she dismissed it as the inevitable convergence of age and activities forcing the women into encounters with men who were already taken. Over time, however, she had come to wonder if her own revelations to them about her torrid and creative sex life, her freedom, and her still-tiny waistline had created a barrier of jealousy. After all, there were teachers and soccer coaches and recent divorcees and widowers running around, and she had made it clear that anyone between the ages of 35 and 57 was welcome. Her mobile phone vibrated in her purse and she snatched it up hoping for a dinner companion. Though she had convinced herself that she needed some alone time, it was the last thing she wanted.
“Honey, is that you?”
“Hi Mom,” she said, dejected. “And before you ask, nothing’s wrong. I was just thinking you were someone else.”
“A male someone else?” her mother asked with an expectant tone?
“No, a girlfriend. Where are you?”
“Well, I’m still down in Memphis cleaning up the house. Your Aunt sure was a packrat. Are you going to make it down this weekend for the funeral?”
“I can’t. I have a huge caseload, mom,” she lied. The truth was, she just didn’t want to be bothered. Andrea like her aunt well enough when she was little, but she had to admit that she got a little creeped by the though of looking at her in a box. “I really wish I could. I am having a casket crown of calla lilies” She would have to remember to actually have it sent.
“Oh, dear, that is so thoughtful. You were her favorite, you know. I know she’ll feel your spirit there.”
“Sorry I can’t make it. Is everything OK. Plans made and all that?”
“Well, we got through with the lawyers today. It looks like she remembered you very fondly. You’ll be getting something from the lawyers directly in the mail, but I think your share of Marnie’s estate totals about $100,000. It’s just you and your sister who get everything,” Andrea’s mother paused. “It was easy to divide up. I mean, no husband, no kids, just her two favorite nieces. I sure wish you could make it, but the flowers, that’s a nice touch. You and Marnie shared a love for those calla lilies, didn’t you?”
“When are you coming home?”
“Well, there’s a lot to do, hon, so probably not for about a week. We’ll put the house up for sale and get that all squared away. And the fall is so nice here, your dad and I thought we’d just have a little vacation. Sure we can’t persuade you to come down?”
“It’s not that I don’t want to, “ she said.
“No, no, I completely understand, dear. You do what you have to do. Marnie would have understood. Gotta run. A bunch of women from high school – can you believe it – want to get together for dinner tonight.”
“Bye mom.”
Walking up Massachusetts Avenue, she was struck by how yuppified the street had become since 1985 when she first moved to Boston from USC. Back then, the place was filled with non-profit organizations, Indian restaurants, and wash houses. Now, there were cafes and bookstores and eateries to cater to the can’t-quite-make-Boston prices crowd, which meant the place was lousy with baby joggers and women in pedal pushers chatting about poopy diapers and how giving up their jobs made them better people, which increasingly was what her monthly “girls night out” ventures were deteriorating into.
What were once discussions about drinks and movies and current events and politics and work and men men men, ended up being more about vomit stain removal, the best way to get a toddler to eat spinach, and why working was so over-rated. Over time, she had been inadvertently pushed to the inside of the table, where she would sit, smiling meekly at the occasional reference to her.
“Oh, Andrea, you should be thanking your stars you don’t have to deal with this. My little Toby broke my bed table and the lamp.”
“Wear that blouse while you can, girl. After you have a baby, silk goes out the window.”
When Andrea did try to bring the subject back around to jobs or politics, she got a flurry of dismissive waves coupled with a smattering of comments that swung the pendulum right back to babies:
“I used to care about the war, but now I am waging my own battle trying to get little whatshername into Fancy-Pants preschool (gratuitous laughter). Do you know they want ten grand a year?”
“Andrea, you are so fashionable. Look at this old frock I’m wearing. Hey! Did anyone TiVo the Sesame Street episode with Alicia Keys?”
She played it straight, pretending to be bored by the whole discussion. In reality, she was broken inside, longing for the stained blouses and sleep deprivation that her erstwhile co-workers were complaining about, and wishing she, too, was too busy being a mom to notice that her hair wasn’t combed. She ached for their complaints. At 42 she fully expected to be outfitted in the trappings of a Boston stay-at-home mom. Instead, she was walking to a bar for dinner, harboring, simultaneously, contempt and jealousy for the women who were somewhere living their meaningless, spit-up filled, undersexed lives.
Andrea checked her messages to see if Tony had called. Like the ones before him, he was involved, but this time it was just an engagement. He hadn’t called. It had been several days. Perhaps she should not have slept with him the first night.
She picked up her mobile phone and made a call to her secretary’s voice mail to have calla lilies sent to her aunt, and stepped into The Harvest.
CHAPTER THREE
The Harvest is at the back edge of Cambridge, close enough to the Harvard campus to give parents a nice place to take their children during Freshman Parent’s Weekend, and just a tad expensive to keep college students from using it as a hangout. The food is upscale, if earthy, giving it a more Cambridge-esque feel, and the clientele is quiet and introspective. From time to time, she’d take some bookish law professor to dinner there on the firm’s dime and drop $500 bucks without blinking, showering him with Joel Thackrey wines in exchange for some advice on a legal matter.
Unlike the more cosmopolitan crowd across the river in Boston, no one would take notice of a single woman having a drink and dinner over a book. Indeed, the bar was likely to be full of singles all engaged in more heady pursuits than trying to get laid.
Andrea headed for the bar, only to discovery that a large 60th birthday party was waiting to be seated. All the tables in the bar were full and there was no quiet corner table for her to sit and pretend to be engaged in a book. She pushed her way through to the bar and grabbed on of the few open barstools available. The bartender waved at her and made a silent gesture that let her know he’d be with her as soon as he dispensed with the giant crowd that had preceded her.
“What can I do for you?” he said, in the momentary lull between the first and second drink crush. “This is a little unusual for a Thursday, but we got a big party in here.”
“So I see. I’ll just have a diet coke.” She said. Had she been at one of her regular Boston haunts, she would have ordered something designed to invite conversation. A chocolate martini was her current favorite, or if the place was more sports-like, a single malt scotch would attract an investment banker who would comment on her fortitude. At Aviva, she might order a Herradura and Cointreau margarita, up, with a ring of black salt. Any man reading Maxxim or GQ would immediately recognize her as a sophisticate. She liked them all, so what did it matter the flavor. At the Harvest, however, in her black dum-dum pantsuit with little if any skin showing, she wasn’t on the prowl.
“Would you like to eat dinner at the bar or will it just be a Diet Coke for you this evening?” the bar tender asked, reaching down for a flatware set-up and a placemat.
“Why not,” said Andrea, smiling at the man in the navy suit next to her. He smiled back, then went back to his beer and his menu. His place was also set for dinner. He wasn’t attractive. No wonder he didn’t have a wedding ring, she thought. There will be no incentive to talk to this guy. She sipped her Diet Coke and waited for the bartender to bring her a menu.
“I can’t figure out what looks good,” he said to no one in particular. “What the hell is gremolata anyway?”
“Lemon and parsley sauce,” she said, without looking up from her menu.
“Hmmm, no, that’s not what I want. Well, since no good deed goes unpunished, perhaps you would be kind enough to explain what mache is?” Oh Christ, he’s trying to engage me.
“It’s sort of lettuce, like a cross between arugula and baby spinach,” she said, and looked down again. His face was scarred from acne he must have had 20-plus years ago, and he wore tiny wire glasses. The suit was nice, expensively tailored even, but it wasn’t pretty enough to detract from the pits and fissures in his skin.
“Thank you. Beauty and brains. Do you eat here often or do you just follow the mache?”
Oh no no no no no no, not the do-you-come-here-often line. Next hell ask me if I work out Listen, skank-boy, I’m out of your league, even if you are a little amusing.
“No, actually I live in Back Bay, so it’s not that convenient.” Andrea put the driest spin she could on the words. Maybe he would go away.
“I just discovered this place. It’s nice. And what food I recognize actually looks pretty good. I confess that I thought I knew a little something about food, but all this new vittle nomenclature is making me realize that the last time I talked knowledgably about food I think I was deciding between the boysenberry and maple syrup.” It made her smile, but she didn’t want to give him the impression that she was available for chatting up.
“So, what are you, the night host at the Chinatown Denny’s?” she asked, sarcastically, hoping the slightly deprecating comment would make him leave her alone.
“Actually, I’m a lawyer, but in retrospect, I guess it doesn’t matter what I am because either way I’d give the same advice: always order the Grand Slam breakfast and stay away from the cocktail lounge after 1am.” This made her laugh. He was ugly but funny. Fun-gly. And he was a lawyer, which explained the nice suit.
“I’m a lawyer, too.” She offered.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “Should we blow this place and head for a 12 step program before it’s too late? What kind of law do you practice?” he asked, then said, “Hey, do you want to put our name in and grab a table? Maybe we could get out of this noise and have a decent dinner. What do you say?” He smiled at her and offered his hand.
“I’m… I’m sort of involved. I . . . was not actually planning to eat.” She lied.
“Listen, don’t apologize. As long as you won’t grow old, living with 11 cats and wearing your winter coat in the summer, my work is done here,” he said with a wink, evidently accustomed to the rebuke. He smiled at her and said, “I’ll let you get back to your book, there.”
Now, of course, she had to leave. She left a $5.00 on the table and thanked him for his company before scooting out the door. A cab. That’s what she needed. She would just go home and forage in the fridge for something to eat. She slipped into one that was just letting out a fare and gave him the address of her Dartmouth Street condo. Her mobile rang. It was her sister.
“Did mom tell you that Aunt Marnie left us each like a hundred grand?” Andrea was silent. She was not in a place that anyone could reach. She thought about the encounter she had just had and considered briefly going back to the Harvest to find the stranger.
“I am going to die,” said Andrea.
“What?!”
“I am going to end up wearing my winter coat in the summer and living with 11 cats.”
“Dre, what are you talking about?” asked her sister, some heightened concern in her voice. “Are you drunk or something?”
“Will you make me a promise, Julie?”
“OK, you are drunk, but yes, I will make you a promise. What?”
“Will you put calla lilies on my coffin?”
September 15, 2005
Boston, MA
To let me know you made it home
Don't want nothin' to be wrong
With part time lover
“Let me be clear,” said Andrea’s 200-an-hour shrink. “Married men do not leave their wives. I really need you to understand that, if you’re going to reach your stated goal.”
“Some do,” said Andrea, thinking of her friend, Bethamy. Bethamy didn’t even want to marry this guy, and one day he just showed up on her door, flanked by two suitcases, and told her he left his wife. And he was loaded to-boot. “And anyway, this one’s only engaged, so that’s fair game, right?”
“Well, to the extent that people are together by choice, everyone is fair game, married, engaged, or otherwise,” said her therapist. “But you need to understand the pattern that you have established, and the pattern of people you find. This is – what – your sixth relationship with a man who is involved?”
Who the hell knew? As if her shrink could read her mind, the woman added, “I suspect there are more than six and this is not about coincidence, Andrea Not only are these men not available emotionally to you, but your reasons for desiring them in the first place stem from this competitive thing you have with other women. Men are only really attractive to you when you are competing for their affection with someone you believe thinks she’s better than you. It’s got to stop if what you want is a lasting relationship. There’s always time to find the right person and there’s no single way to go about it, but at 42, we generally expect that people have had at least one committed relationship.” The therapist paused and breathed, as if trying to forestall what she would say next. She folded her notebook and leaned forward. When she did speak, her voice was low.
“I’m not going to moralize on whether coming on to married men is wrong, but I know it’s a wrong choice for you because you’ve been clear about wanting a long-term partner. Sleeping with committed men excludes the likelihood that you can have a committed relationship. It’s pretty simple from a behavioral perspective.”
Andrea bit her upper lip to push back the tears. She didn’t want to cry. All she wanted was someone to love her. It was all she ever wanted. She didn’t know why she kept getting the married ones and non-committing ones. She didn’t. She looked out the window so her therapist wouldn’t see her blinking back tears. This wasn’t helping, she thought to herself. This woman is just telling me I’m a bad person. Again with the mind-reading:
“Andrea,” said her therapist, holding out a tissue box, “this is why you’re here, to work through these issues. But the thing is, you have to start with some behavioral changes. We’ll get into some of your competition issues in the weeks to come, but the behavioral change you have to make now is this: stop dating men who are already involved.”
“But they come on to me,” Andrea pointed out, remembering how Tony had approached her at the law firm mixer. Didn’t he know he was engaged at the time? This was all so unfair. It was as if she was being penalized for her charm. She hated men sometimes.
“People will approach you all the time with propositions of one kind or another. You will never be able to control that; this is about your choices,” the therapist said. “And just we are clear, it is perfectly appropriate to ask a man if he is already involved.”
Oh yeah, thought Andrea, that’s a real turn on at a party: Hi, I’m Andrea. Before we start talking, do you mind telling me if you have a girlfriend or wife? But she held her tongue, at least on that point. Besides, it wasn’t just about that. She felt real chemistry with the men she met; this wasn’t anecdotal coincidence related to the love of the same ice cream flavor, nor was it any longer just a romp in the sack. Perhaps years ago the latter might have been a motivator, but now she had no reason to waste her time on involved men. Andrea was looking for a mate – and she was finding them. She wanted to give that a chance. These were deeper connections that mere physical attraction.
“How do you just stop being attracted to someone,” Andrea challenged the shrink.
“Andrea, this is a dangerous game you’re playing with yourself, creating a monomaniacal fiction that these men are the only ones for you and that they feel the same way. How many ‘he’s-the-only-one-for-me’ men have you had? And in every case, they’ve ended badly. Remember the lawyer?”
She remembered. She had met Derek at a party. And while the ring on his finger told her he was probably married, it didn’t signal that he was married to a ruthless bitch.
In short order, he had become the love of her life and she knew the feeling was mutual. He had asked her to be patient; that he and his wife were going through a bad patch, but that if things continued to go south with his wife, he would make their relationship permanent. He empathized with her status, and often commented on the strength and self-confidence it took to be content with a non-traditional relationship. He often commented on her elevated spiritual plane of operation and her independence, which he found sexy. Then, without notice, he told her it was off. He was going to try to make a go of it. His wife was pregnant and he was happy and their good times were nothing more than a fling. Poof! Gone. Kicked to the curb like Monday’s trash.
Their talks had been too intense, their sex too intimate for merely a fling. He had bared his heart to her. She knew his deepest fears and he hers. She had recently counseled him in a real estate purchase that he said was an investment, she assumed, for his and Andrea’s future. Why else would he buy property in Natick if not for a little home to raise their children. Their future. They even talked about what baby names the liked. He called her every day, even sent flowers to her office (love, me). This sudden privation was his wife’s unborn baby talking, not Derek.
Surely, his wife would be inclined to leave him if she knew the truth of their spiritual connection. It was pretty clear that a wife who was 24-7 at the office wasn’t providing him with what he needed, or else why would Derek be coming to Andrea? By revealing herself as his true soul mate, Andrea wasn’t trying to hurt anyone (though she knew someone would be hurt), she was merely trying to create a space for her and Derek. Men, by their nature, were cowardly, so she couldn’t count on him to do the right thing for the two of them. Thinking about it then, their connection was positively compulsory, and in the end, by revealing the true nature of their relationship to his wife, Andrea was really only accelerating the inevitable. She found the wife’s email address (not hard, using the web) and sent an email from her office account.
That’s how the email began. It went on to suggest that the two women talk. Andrea made sure the email was tasteful and dignified, not some seamy or nasty communication that might be seen on Jerry Springer. After all, there was another woman involved who would surely be hurt by what was contained in it. It was only right to consider her feelings in all this.
There had been no response for a week; neither had Derek returned her phone calls. Perhaps they were working out the separation between them; how and when he would leave. She would do the right thing and give him space. Then, the phone rang.
“What are you? Some sort of serial fuck-buddy?” said the woman at the other end of the phone. Andrea knew instantly who it was.
“There’s no need to be nasty,” said Andrea, trying to keep her composure.
“Let me get this straight: you spread your legs for my husband and I’m the one who’s nasty? Does a wedding ring mean anything to you?”
“Derek loves me.”
“Is that what you think?” the woman on the other end had started to chuckle. “You really are pathetic. Let me set you straight. First, Derek has done this before, and just so we’re clear, when he got busted this time, his excuse was that he used you for free legal advice for our vacation home. And I’ve done my homework on you. Before you started sleeping with every married man in Boston, maybe you should have thought about your college days. USC Sorority girls grow up and get morals! Some do, anyway. Your pink-and-green sisters tell me you’re all about the married men like it’s some sickness. Well, you fucked with the wrong bitch this time, you fucking cunt.”
“I don’t need to listen to this,” said Andrea, indignant that her attempts at civility were being rebuked. “I was trying to save you and your baby the pain of being in a loveless relationship.”
“Oh is that how you justify it? Where are my manners. Here’s how I’m showing my gratitude. Remember John Kinney? Guess whose wife just got saved too.”
“That is none of your business,” snapped Andrea. “Anyway, what do you know? You can’t prove any thing.”
“You shouldn’t share certain, shall we say fellatious, Polaroids with your girlfriends, honey. Oh yeah, I can prove it alright. And I got a list of more names, too. I plan do save women all over the tri-state area, which appears to be your hunting ground. My marriage may be over, but so are you. “
Andrea had tried to remain calm. This was backfiring in a big way. “I can sue you for defamation, and you should know I’m an attorney.”
“I’m an attorney, too, bitch. Let me give you a torts lesson since you obviously missed it in first year law school: it’s only actionable if it’s false.” Then she had hung up.
Things had not worked as planned, and to save herself, Andrea called a friend in the city attorney’s office for advice on how to stave off this woman’s campaign. Without thinking, he agreed to write a nasty letter, on City Attorney letterhead, threatening legal action and an ethics investigation if the woman disparaged Andrea. In hindsight, it had been stupid at so many levels. Derek’s wife had gotten the friend fired, and she never heard from Derek again (though she did get a certain satisfaction upon hearing of his divorce). Perhaps if she had handled it differently, they’d still be together.
Andrea left the bad memory and sank into her therapist’s leather armchair. That had not been a good break-up, but at least she was right about the marriage. She turned to her therapist.
“I agree that breakup was a mess, but first of all, I was right, wasn’t I? It was a loveless marriage. And second of all, it wasn’t my fault how things turned out. Who knew that woman would be so crazy.”
“This is always someone else’s fault, isn’t it, Andrea?” the therapist said. “Tell me, do you shoulder any of the responsibility for the things that affect you?”
“Of course. I’m here, aren’t I? I just don’t think I should be the villain all the time. I’m giving these men something they need, they obviously gravitate to me because of who I am, and it’s not up to me to sustain their marriages, is it?”
“That’s a moral question that has more to do with the type of society you want to live in and how you feel about supporting the choices that other people make,” said the therapist. “We’re not necessarily here to change the world; we’re here to get you what you want. That said, remember that the shoe could be on the other foot someday, Andrea, and you want to know that strangers out there support – or at least respect -- your choice to be in a monogamous relationship.”
“ Well, I don’t support people being miserable and you know, these men are miserable before they come to me. I don’t force anyone to sleep with me. They are obviously still searching for something and they find me.”
“Is this way of relationship building getting you what you want in life?”
“If it were, would I be sitting here?” Andrea’s sarcasm and general annoyance and pedantic women like her shrink was beginning to show. “I’m just saying that I’m not a bad person.”
Her therapist smiled at her and put down the tissue box. She spoke softly. “I know all of this is tough.. We’ll talk next week. Remember that therapy is based upon your own self-reporting, and your own hard look at your behavior. I have to trust what you tell me, but I’ve also been in this game long enough to know all the tricks. To move past your issues, you have to be honest with yourself and with me. I’ll see you next week?”
Andrea nodded and shook off the comfort of the leather chair to get her coat. Though she knew the time, she instinctively looked at her watch 6:50pm. The September weather was prescient of cooler temperatures to come, but today, it was a perfect Boston night. Maybe a drink on the patio at Rivaud. Or some drinks and soup at the Harvest across Smoots bridge in Cambridge. Andrea’s psychologist meeting today precluded a visit to the gym, so she decided to walk.. She punched in the number of a girlfriend, but left no message when voicemail picked up. She tried another. And another. Dinner for one, it seemed, was on the menu. She contemplated briefly having dinner at a bar, but decided she wasn’t in the mood for flirting tonight. A quiet evening at the Harvest in Cambridge might be the perfect place to nest. She would stop by the bookstore and pick up something juicy.
These days, fewer and fewer of her girlfriends could make a last minute dinner invitation. Most were encumbered in some way: married, partnered, kids. Her impromptu invitations competed head-to-head with their bake sale duties, television shows, or just the need to be with their families. All too often, she was the barfly at the end of the night, flirting with some drunk investment banker whose T card and cash had fallen out of his pocket and who was trying to figure out his own phone number. Left and right, her friends were “calling it a night” well before she was ready to reacquaint with the newly painted walls of her Back Bay condo. They never had time for her any more. Time was all she had, except, it seemed, for finding a soul mate.
When they did meet her for the occasional lunch or evening drink, they frequently managed to make married life sound horrific. Husband X did this or that thing to piss them off; they were overworked; kids were a pain; sex was non-existent; no time alone. And most of them had let themselves go to the point where Andrea would not have been surprised if their men were getting it on the side, too. To top it off, their muffin top waistlines were stuffed into outfits that should have been put out to Goodwill two years ago. Andrea wouldn’t paint her house in some of the getups they sported outside. To hear them tell it, single life was a welcome breeze in a stifling way of life. They were not only physical blobs, but many of them were bereft of any spiritual intelligence.
Still, it’s one thing to complain about the quality of the sheets when you stay at the Four Season’s, but if you’ve never been there, it’s difficult to sympathize. Although many of her erstwhile hottie friends had become harried, homely, and fat, their complaints rang hollow in Andrea’s ears. She, after all, was not part of the married woman’s club. And at least according to Time Magazine, if you were over 35 and single, you had more chance of being hit by lightening than finding a partner.
They always asked her about the new love in her life, but over time she’d stopped providing too much detail. For one thing, unlike her shrink, her married friends had taken to moralizing about her choices. It wasn’t just the being involved thing, it was her choices in men, generally and/or her reasons for gravitating toward them, all of which was fair game to the married crowd. God forbid you mention that they were letting themselves go, but get one gray hair and suddenly they were all telling her that she ought to cover it up or risk appearing long in the tooth. And there was the age thing. Andrea knew they were trying to help, but there were certain girlfriends who had a way of making her want to slit her wrists in a warm bath.
“Girl, at 42, you really do need to lie about your marital status. People will think you are retarded or something if you haven’t been married at least once. You can always tell him the truth after he’s asked you to marry him,” they’d say. Great, now she was a loser because she hadn’t been divorced? Another one she could see coming from miles away was the maybe-you’re-gay sermon:
“You know, Andrea, there’s nothing wrong with not being attracted to men. This is the 21st century. People don’t care about, you know, if you have a preference for women. In fact, I have a friend who ---- .“ That’s how it would begin.
And despite all of their man-getting advice and helpful suggestions, what was conspicuously missing from their chocolate martini and French fry dinners was the invitation by any of her “friends” to meet an eligible man. At first, she dismissed it as the inevitable convergence of age and activities forcing the women into encounters with men who were already taken. Over time, however, she had come to wonder if her own revelations to them about her torrid and creative sex life, her freedom, and her still-tiny waistline had created a barrier of jealousy. After all, there were teachers and soccer coaches and recent divorcees and widowers running around, and she had made it clear that anyone between the ages of 35 and 57 was welcome. Her mobile phone vibrated in her purse and she snatched it up hoping for a dinner companion. Though she had convinced herself that she needed some alone time, it was the last thing she wanted.
“Honey, is that you?”
“Hi Mom,” she said, dejected. “And before you ask, nothing’s wrong. I was just thinking you were someone else.”
“A male someone else?” her mother asked with an expectant tone?
“No, a girlfriend. Where are you?”
“Well, I’m still down in Memphis cleaning up the house. Your Aunt sure was a packrat. Are you going to make it down this weekend for the funeral?”
“I can’t. I have a huge caseload, mom,” she lied. The truth was, she just didn’t want to be bothered. Andrea like her aunt well enough when she was little, but she had to admit that she got a little creeped by the though of looking at her in a box. “I really wish I could. I am having a casket crown of calla lilies” She would have to remember to actually have it sent.
“Oh, dear, that is so thoughtful. You were her favorite, you know. I know she’ll feel your spirit there.”
“Sorry I can’t make it. Is everything OK. Plans made and all that?”
“Well, we got through with the lawyers today. It looks like she remembered you very fondly. You’ll be getting something from the lawyers directly in the mail, but I think your share of Marnie’s estate totals about $100,000. It’s just you and your sister who get everything,” Andrea’s mother paused. “It was easy to divide up. I mean, no husband, no kids, just her two favorite nieces. I sure wish you could make it, but the flowers, that’s a nice touch. You and Marnie shared a love for those calla lilies, didn’t you?”
“When are you coming home?”
“Well, there’s a lot to do, hon, so probably not for about a week. We’ll put the house up for sale and get that all squared away. And the fall is so nice here, your dad and I thought we’d just have a little vacation. Sure we can’t persuade you to come down?”
“It’s not that I don’t want to, “ she said.
“No, no, I completely understand, dear. You do what you have to do. Marnie would have understood. Gotta run. A bunch of women from high school – can you believe it – want to get together for dinner tonight.”
“Bye mom.”
Walking up Massachusetts Avenue, she was struck by how yuppified the street had become since 1985 when she first moved to Boston from USC. Back then, the place was filled with non-profit organizations, Indian restaurants, and wash houses. Now, there were cafes and bookstores and eateries to cater to the can’t-quite-make-Boston prices crowd, which meant the place was lousy with baby joggers and women in pedal pushers chatting about poopy diapers and how giving up their jobs made them better people, which increasingly was what her monthly “girls night out” ventures were deteriorating into.
What were once discussions about drinks and movies and current events and politics and work and men men men, ended up being more about vomit stain removal, the best way to get a toddler to eat spinach, and why working was so over-rated. Over time, she had been inadvertently pushed to the inside of the table, where she would sit, smiling meekly at the occasional reference to her.
“Oh, Andrea, you should be thanking your stars you don’t have to deal with this. My little Toby broke my bed table and the lamp.”
“Wear that blouse while you can, girl. After you have a baby, silk goes out the window.”
When Andrea did try to bring the subject back around to jobs or politics, she got a flurry of dismissive waves coupled with a smattering of comments that swung the pendulum right back to babies:
“I used to care about the war, but now I am waging my own battle trying to get little whatshername into Fancy-Pants preschool (gratuitous laughter). Do you know they want ten grand a year?”
“Andrea, you are so fashionable. Look at this old frock I’m wearing. Hey! Did anyone TiVo the Sesame Street episode with Alicia Keys?”
She played it straight, pretending to be bored by the whole discussion. In reality, she was broken inside, longing for the stained blouses and sleep deprivation that her erstwhile co-workers were complaining about, and wishing she, too, was too busy being a mom to notice that her hair wasn’t combed. She ached for their complaints. At 42 she fully expected to be outfitted in the trappings of a Boston stay-at-home mom. Instead, she was walking to a bar for dinner, harboring, simultaneously, contempt and jealousy for the women who were somewhere living their meaningless, spit-up filled, undersexed lives.
Andrea checked her messages to see if Tony had called. Like the ones before him, he was involved, but this time it was just an engagement. He hadn’t called. It had been several days. Perhaps she should not have slept with him the first night.
She picked up her mobile phone and made a call to her secretary’s voice mail to have calla lilies sent to her aunt, and stepped into The Harvest.
The Harvest is at the back edge of Cambridge, close enough to the Harvard campus to give parents a nice place to take their children during Freshman Parent’s Weekend, and just a tad expensive to keep college students from using it as a hangout. The food is upscale, if earthy, giving it a more Cambridge-esque feel, and the clientele is quiet and introspective. From time to time, she’d take some bookish law professor to dinner there on the firm’s dime and drop $500 bucks without blinking, showering him with Joel Thackrey wines in exchange for some advice on a legal matter.
Unlike the more cosmopolitan crowd across the river in Boston, no one would take notice of a single woman having a drink and dinner over a book. Indeed, the bar was likely to be full of singles all engaged in more heady pursuits than trying to get laid.
Andrea headed for the bar, only to discovery that a large 60th birthday party was waiting to be seated. All the tables in the bar were full and there was no quiet corner table for her to sit and pretend to be engaged in a book. She pushed her way through to the bar and grabbed on of the few open barstools available. The bartender waved at her and made a silent gesture that let her know he’d be with her as soon as he dispensed with the giant crowd that had preceded her.
“What can I do for you?” he said, in the momentary lull between the first and second drink crush. “This is a little unusual for a Thursday, but we got a big party in here.”
“So I see. I’ll just have a diet coke.” She said. Had she been at one of her regular Boston haunts, she would have ordered something designed to invite conversation. A chocolate martini was her current favorite, or if the place was more sports-like, a single malt scotch would attract an investment banker who would comment on her fortitude. At Aviva, she might order a Herradura and Cointreau margarita, up, with a ring of black salt. Any man reading Maxxim or GQ would immediately recognize her as a sophisticate. She liked them all, so what did it matter the flavor. At the Harvest, however, in her black dum-dum pantsuit with little if any skin showing, she wasn’t on the prowl.
“Would you like to eat dinner at the bar or will it just be a Diet Coke for you this evening?” the bar tender asked, reaching down for a flatware set-up and a placemat.
“Why not,” said Andrea, smiling at the man in the navy suit next to her. He smiled back, then went back to his beer and his menu. His place was also set for dinner. He wasn’t attractive. No wonder he didn’t have a wedding ring, she thought. There will be no incentive to talk to this guy. She sipped her Diet Coke and waited for the bartender to bring her a menu.
“I can’t figure out what looks good,” he said to no one in particular. “What the hell is gremolata anyway?”
“Lemon and parsley sauce,” she said, without looking up from her menu.
“Hmmm, no, that’s not what I want. Well, since no good deed goes unpunished, perhaps you would be kind enough to explain what mache is?” Oh Christ, he’s trying to engage me.
“It’s sort of lettuce, like a cross between arugula and baby spinach,” she said, and looked down again. His face was scarred from acne he must have had 20-plus years ago, and he wore tiny wire glasses. The suit was nice, expensively tailored even, but it wasn’t pretty enough to detract from the pits and fissures in his skin.
“Thank you. Beauty and brains. Do you eat here often or do you just follow the mache?”
Oh no no no no no no, not the do-you-come-here-often line. Next hell ask me if I work out Listen, skank-boy, I’m out of your league, even if you are a little amusing.
“No, actually I live in Back Bay, so it’s not that convenient.” Andrea put the driest spin she could on the words. Maybe he would go away.
“I just discovered this place. It’s nice. And what food I recognize actually looks pretty good. I confess that I thought I knew a little something about food, but all this new vittle nomenclature is making me realize that the last time I talked knowledgably about food I think I was deciding between the boysenberry and maple syrup.” It made her smile, but she didn’t want to give him the impression that she was available for chatting up.
“So, what are you, the night host at the Chinatown Denny’s?” she asked, sarcastically, hoping the slightly deprecating comment would make him leave her alone.
“Actually, I’m a lawyer, but in retrospect, I guess it doesn’t matter what I am because either way I’d give the same advice: always order the Grand Slam breakfast and stay away from the cocktail lounge after 1am.” This made her laugh. He was ugly but funny. Fun-gly. And he was a lawyer, which explained the nice suit.
“I’m a lawyer, too.” She offered.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “Should we blow this place and head for a 12 step program before it’s too late? What kind of law do you practice?” he asked, then said, “Hey, do you want to put our name in and grab a table? Maybe we could get out of this noise and have a decent dinner. What do you say?” He smiled at her and offered his hand.
“I’m… I’m sort of involved. I . . . was not actually planning to eat.” She lied.
“Listen, don’t apologize. As long as you won’t grow old, living with 11 cats and wearing your winter coat in the summer, my work is done here,” he said with a wink, evidently accustomed to the rebuke. He smiled at her and said, “I’ll let you get back to your book, there.”
Now, of course, she had to leave. She left a $5.00 on the table and thanked him for his company before scooting out the door. A cab. That’s what she needed. She would just go home and forage in the fridge for something to eat. She slipped into one that was just letting out a fare and gave him the address of her Dartmouth Street condo. Her mobile rang. It was her sister.
“Did mom tell you that Aunt Marnie left us each like a hundred grand?” Andrea was silent. She was not in a place that anyone could reach. She thought about the encounter she had just had and considered briefly going back to the Harvest to find the stranger.
“I am going to die,” said Andrea.
“What?!”
“I am going to end up wearing my winter coat in the summer and living with 11 cats.”
“Dre, what are you talking about?” asked her sister, some heightened concern in her voice. “Are you drunk or something?”
“Will you make me a promise, Julie?”
“OK, you are drunk, but yes, I will make you a promise. What?”
“Will you put calla lilies on my coffin?”
